Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 5/1.
Gabriel's Restaurant and Bakery
  • Order Online
  • Digital Gift Cards
  • Bakery Online Orders
  • About
  • Holiday Orders
  • Menus
    Menu Dessert Menu Monthly Dessert Special
  • Catering
  • Wedding & Specialty Cakes
    Cake Consultation Cake Flavors Cake Pricing
  • Events
  • Contact
    Contact Us Work With Us
  • The Market
  • Order Catering
Dessert Menu

Dessert Menu

Southern Sweets VIPSign up to receive a free slice of cake on your Birthday!

Dessert Menu

Individual Desserts

Fresh Fruit Tarts

$7.50

Shortbread crust filled with pastry cream and topped with fresh fruit.

Fresh Fruit Tarts
1 review
11 pop1 review
 

Key Lime Tarts

$3.75

Graham Cracker crust filled with our house made Key Lime pie filling.

123 pops
 

Chocolate Salted Caramel Tarts

$2.25

A mini tart shell filled with our cooked caramel topped with chocolate ganache and a tiny sprinkle of sea salt.

1 review
 

Banana Pudding

$3.50

Southern staple! Vanilla pudding made from scratch, fresh bananas, vanilla wafers topped with whipped cream.

Banana Pudding
2 reviews
44 pops2 reviews
 

Flourless Chocolate Hearts

$3.25

Decadent chocolate hearts glazed with chocolate ganache. Gluten-friendly

Flourless Chocolate Hearts
3 reviews
617 pops3 reviews
 

Mini Fruit Tarts

$2.40

A sweet mini size of our fabulous fruit tart. A perfect bite! (12 minimum)

Mini Fruit Tarts
2 reviews
11 pop2 reviews
 

Mini Key Lime Tarts

$1.70

A perfect bite of Key Lime pie. (12 minimum)

224 pops
 

GF Strawberry Cupcake

$3.75

Fresh strawberries baked into our gluten friendly cake batter. Gluten-friendly

33 pops
 

Cannoli

$2.25

Cannoli shells filled with our mascarpone and marsala wine cream filling.

Cannoli
 

Rice Krispie Treats

$2.95

Classic treat. Kid and adult favorite.

 

Cupcakes

$2.75

Our famous cake flavors made in a cupcake size. (6 of each flavor)

Cupcakes
3 reviews
617 pops3 reviews
 

Gluten Friendly Yellow Cake: Chocolate Buttercream or Vanilla Buttercream

$3.75

Everyone gets cupcakes! Gluten-friendly

GF
 

Crème Brulee

$3

Our cooked custard with caramelized sugar on top. Fan favorite! 
Gluten-friendly

 

Chocolate Strawberries

$1.55

Fresh strawberries dipped in chocolate or white chocolate. Gluten Friendly

Chocolate Strawberries
11 pop
 

Layer Cakes

Caramel Cake

Yellow layers filled and frosted in our house-made cooked caramel.

4" $107" $24.959" $42.50
Caramel Cake
9 reviews
92213 pops9 reviews
 

Double Fudge Cake/ Buttercream

Double Fudge Layers with choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream. Also available in gluten-friendly

4" $107" $24.959" $41.25GF 4" $12.50GF 7" $27.95GF 9" $50.50
99 pops7 reviews
 

Fresh Coconut Cake

Our fresh coconut cake iced with 7-minute icing and covered with fresh coconut.

4" $117" $24.959" $44.50
Fresh Coconut Cake
1 review
617 pops1 review
 

Red Velvet Cake

Southern Red Velvet with pecan cream cheese icing.

7" $24.954" $109" $40.50
Red Velvet Cake
43 reviews
463655 pops43 reviews
 

Yellow Cake: Chocolate Buttercream or Vanilla Buttercream

9" GF $50.507" GF $29.954" GF $12.509" $40.507" $24.954" $10
Yellow Cake: Chocolate Buttercream or Vanilla Buttercream
5 reviews
112 pops5 reviews
 

Carrot Cake

Freshly grated carrots, pecans and spices in our traditional carrot cake, iced in our cream cheese-pecan frosting.

4" $117" $24.959" $42.50
Carrot Cake
12 reviews
1616 pops12 reviews
 

Double Fudge Cake/Cooked Fudge Icing

We make our cooked fudge over the stove just like Grandma did.

4" $107" $24.959" $42.50
81110 pops5 reviews
 

German Chocolate Cake

Just like Mama made. German chocolate cake frosted with cooked pecan-coconut icing. Fan favorite!

9" $42.507" $27.954" $11.50
German Chocolate Cake
7 reviews
151319 pops7 reviews
 

Fresh Strawberry Cake

4" $11.507" $29.959" $464" GF $12.507" GF $29.959" GF $56
Fresh Strawberry Cake
49 reviews
842288 pops49 reviews
 

Chocolate Pecan

Double Fudge and pecan layers frosted with cooked fudge and pecans.

4" $127" $27.959" $44
213 pops
 

Italian Cream Cake

Full of pecans and coconut, iced with cream cheese icing topped with more pecans and coconut.

4" $10.507" $24.959" $44
Italian Cream Cake
7 reviews
1313 pops7 reviews
 

Hummingbird Cake

Fresh bananas, pineapple, pecan and cinnamon iced in our house-made cream cheese frosting.

4" $117" $24.959" $43.50
Hummingbird Cake
9 reviews
20323 pops9 reviews
 

Yellow Cake: Cooked Fudge Icing

9" $42.507" $24.954" $10
628 pops3 reviews
 

Pound Cake

Plain Pound w/ Caramel Icing

Large $28.75Small $14.50
Plain Pound w/ Caramel Icing
5 reviews
415 pops5 reviews
 

Plain Pound

Large $21.75Small $11
55 pops4 reviews
 

Raspberry Swirled Lemon Pound

Take our perfect pound and swirl raspberry and lemon in it. Delicious!

Large $30.75Small $15.50
11 pop2 reviews
 

Coconut Pound

Coconut pound cake topped with coconut glaze and fresh coconut.

Large $30Small $15
11 pop
 

Plain Pound w/ Cooked Fudge Icing

Large Round $26.50Small Round $14
22 pops
 

Lemon Glazed Pound

Large Round $27.25Small Round $14
Lemon Glazed Pound
3 reviews
22 pops3 reviews
 

Buttered Rum with Pecans

Just like it sounds... Butter and rum glaze topped with pecans.

Large $33.75Small $16.95
213 pops3 reviews
 

Bars

Lemon Bars

$1

Shortbread crust with our fresh lemon baked curd on top. Sprinkle with powder sugar and you have a classic lemon bar.

Lemon Bars
11 pop
 

Caramel Walnut Brownies

$1.30

Chocolate brownies topped with our house made caramel, chocolate drizzle and a sprinkle of walnuts.

 

Brownies

$0.95

We use 2 different chocolates in this brownie and spread chocolate frosting on top. Chocolate, chocolate, chocolate!

gluten-free +$1.25
22 pops1 review
 

Pecan Brownies

$1.30

Pecans added to our decadent brownies with chocolate brownie icing.

Pecan Brownies
213 pops
 

Crème De Menthe Brownies

$1.30

Chocolate brownie base, creme de menthe filling. Topped with chocolate ganache.

22 pops1 review
 

Blondies

$1.05

A chocolate-less brownie is a blondie. A butter brown sugar based bar with our coconut-pecan icing

22 pops1 review
 

Quick Breads

Pumpkin Bread

House made pumpkin bread great anytime of the year.

Large $16.50Small $9.25
11 pop2 reviews
 

Banana Nut Bread

Made with fresh bananas and chopped walnuts.

Large $16.50Small $9.25
11 pop3 reviews
 

Blueberry Bread

Also comes in muffins and a variety of sizes.

Large $19.50Small $9.75
 

Morning Options

Muffins

$2.65

Available in Blueberry, Cranberry Orange, Morning Glory, Banana.
Pumpkin available Nov-Dec only

Muffins
11 pop
 

Pies

Dutch Apple Pie

$24.95

We peel and cut Granny Smith apples and bake into this classic apple pie topped with a brown sugar streusel.

Dutch Apple Pie
1 review
1 review
 

Pecan Pie

$24.95

Southern tradition of pecans and filling baked up right.

Pecan Pie
1 review
527 pops1 review
 

Fudge Pie

$22

Baked Fudge pie. Perfect with a dollop of whipped cream.

Fudge Pie
11 pop
 

Tollhouse Pie

$22

Chocolate and walnut filling. Perfect warmed up with vanilla ice cream.

Tollhouse Pie
55 pops
 

Key Lime Pie

$29.95

Key lime custard baked in a graham cracker crust. Topped with whipped cream.

Key Lime Pie
11 pop
 

Stacks

Specialty & Seasonal Desserts

Lemon Meringue Pie

$21.95

Seasonal pie / check for availability.

 

Peppermint Brownies

$1.30

Brownies filled with peppermint schnapps creme and topped with chocolate ganache. (Dec)

 

Pumpkin Pie

$22

House made with just a touch of rum. (Oct-Dec)

112 pops
 

Yule Log

$27

Chiffon cake filled with praline pastry cream and iced in chocolate buttercream. (Dec Only)

11 pop
 

Cookies

Snickerdoodle

$1.65

Butter cookie dough rolled in cinnamon and sugar.

Snickerdoodle
516 pops
 

Chocolate Chunk

$1.65

Big chunks of chocolate fill these classic cookies.

213 pops1 review
 

Sugar

$1.65

Our sugar cookie dough rolled in seasonal sprinkles

Sugar
11 pop
 

Peanut Butter

$1.65

Soft chewy large peanut butter cookies.

44 pops
 

Oatmeal Raisin

$1.65

Oatmeal cookies made from scratch.

11 pop
 

Gourmet Cookies

Chewbilee

$1.95

White chocolate, walnuts and craisins. Johnnie's favorite!

22 pops
 

Chocolate Toffee

$1.95

Chocolate cookie dough with toffee pieces and walnuts.

11 pop2 reviews
 

Decorated Sugar

$2.85

Cut out seasonal cookies. Custom orders made for your special events are available.

44 pops
 

Cheddar Cheese buttons

Cheddar Cheese buttons

Made from scratch with a hint of cayenne. We can't keep them on the shelves they are so popular!

Per Bag (24) $4.99
 
Show All Items
GFGluten-Free
Made with by Popmenu
Gabriel's Restaurant and Bakery
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window