Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Individual Desserts

Fresh Fruit Tarts

$7.50

Shortbread crust filled with pastry cream and topped with fresh fruit.

Key Lime Tarts

$3.75

Graham Cracker crust filled with our house made Key Lime pie filling.

11 pop

Chocolate Salted Caramel Tart

$2.25

A mini tart shell filled with our cooked caramel topped with chocolate ganache and a tiny sprinkle of sea salt.

Crème Brulee

Our cooked custard with caramelized sugar on top. Fan favorite!
Gluten-friendly

Cakepops

$1.75

Comes in Yellow, Strawberry or Double Fudge. (12 minimum)
Gluten-friendly - 1.95

11 pop

Flourless Chocolate Hearts

$3.25

Decadent chocolate hearts glazed with chocolate ganache. Gluten-friendly

1 review

33 pops1 review

Mini Fruit Tarts

$2.40

A sweet mini size of our fabulous fruit tart. A perfect bite! (12 minimum)

Mini Key Lime Tarts

$1.70

A perfect bite of Key Lime pie. (12 minimum)

213 pops

Petit Fours

$1.50

Perfect for teas, showers or any gathering. A hint of almond flavor covered with glossy fondant. Comes with your choice of rosebud or baby booties. Custom designs available. (12 minimum)

235 pops

Eclairs

House made pate choux filled with our pastry cream and dipped in chocolate. (12 minimum)

1 review

Cannoli

$2.25

Cannoli shells filled with our mascarpone and marsala wine cream filling.

Rice Krispie Treats

$2.95

Classic treat. Kid and adult favorite.

Cupcakes

$2.75

Our famous cake flavors made in a cupcake size. (12 of each flavor)

415 pops3 reviews

GF Yellow/ Double Fudge Cupcake

$3.75

Everyone gets cupcakes! Gluten-friendly

GF Strawberry Cupcake

$3.75

Fresh strawberries baked into our gluten friendly cake batter. Gluten-friendly

11 pop

Banana Pudding

$3.50

Southern staple! Vanilla pudding made from scratch, fresh bananas, vanilla wafers topped with whipped cream.

1 review

11 pop1 review

Chocolate Strawberries

$1.55

Fresh strawberries dipped in chocolate or white chocolate. Gluten Friendly

Layer Cakes

Caramel Cake

Yellow layers filled and frosted in our house-made cooked caramel.

4" $107" $24.959" $42.50

2 reviews

44 pops2 reviews

Double Fudge Cake/ Buttercream

Double Fudge Layers with choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream. Also available in gluten-friendly

4" $107" $24.959" $41.25GF 4" $12.50GF 7" $27.95GF 9" $50.50

66 pops3 reviews

Fresh Coconut Cake

Our fresh coconut cake iced with 7-minute icing and covered with fresh coconut.

4" $117" $24.959" $44.50

22 pops

Red Velvet Cake

Southern Red Velvet with pecan cream cheese icing.

4" $107" $24.959" $40.50

13 reviews

221124 pops13 reviews

Yellow Cake/Cooked Fudge Icing

4" $107" $24.959" $42.50

1 review

112 pops1 review

Carrot Cake

Freshly grated carrots, pecans and spices in our traditional carrot cake, iced in our cream cheese-pecan frosting.

4" $117" $24.959" $42.50

99 pops4 reviews

Double Fudge Cake/Cooked Fudge Icing

We make our cooked fudge over the stove just like Grandma did.

4" $107" $24.959" $42.50

5117 pops1 review

German Chocolate Cake

Just like Mama made. German chocolate cake frosted with cooked pecan-coconut icing. Fan favorite!

4" $117" $24.959" $42.50

2 reviews

819 pops2 reviews

Fresh Strawberry Cake

Most popular cake made with fresh strawberries folded in our yellow cake batter frosted with a cream cheese buttercream icing with fresh strawberries folded in. Also available in gluten-friendly.

4" $10.507" $27.959" $444" GF $12.507" GF $29.959" GF $56

19 reviews

44145 pops19 reviews

Yellow Cake/Buttercream

Vanilla layers with choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream. Also available in gluten-friendly.

4" $107" $24.959" $40.504" GF $12.507" GF $29.959" GF $50.50

1 review

Chocolate Pecan

Double Fudge and pecan layers frosted with cooked fudge and pecans.

4" $127" $27.959" $44

112 pops

Italian Cream Cake

Full of pecans and coconut, iced with cream cheese icing topped with more pecans and coconut.

4" $10.507" $24.959" $44

3 reviews

1010 pops3 reviews

Hummingbird Cake

Fresh bananas, pineapple, pecan and cinnamon iced in our house-made cream cheese frosting.

4" $117" $24.959" $43.50

11112 pops1 review

White Lady Cake

Double fudge layers filled and iced with white chocolate mousse and covered with chocolate curls.

4" $127" $27.959" $44

99 pops3 reviews

Pound Cake

Plain Pound/Caramel Icing

Our butter based pound cake topped with house made caramel.

Small $14Large $24.50

1 review

11 pop1 review

Plain Pound

Classic recipe for our plain pound. Butter, sugar, eggs and flour. Classic!

Small $10.50Large $19

11 pop1 review

Raspberry Swirled Lemon Pound

Take our perfect pound and swirl raspberry and lemon in it. Delicious!

Small $14.50Large $26.75

11 pop1 review

Coconut Pound

Coconut pound cake topped with coconut glaze and fresh coconut.

Small $14.50Large $26

Plain Pound/Cooked Fudge Icing

Small $14Large $24.50

11 pop

Lemon Glazed Pound

Our guests favorite pound cake. Covered in our fresh lemon glaze.

Small $14Large $24.50

1 review

Buttered Rum with Pecans

Just like it sounds... Butter and rum glaze topped with pecans.

Small $15Large $30

11 pop1 review

Bars

Lemon Bars

Shortbread crust with our fresh lemon baked curd on top. Sprinkle with powder sugar and you have a classic lemon bar.

11 pop

Caramel Walnut Brownies

$1.30

Chocolate brownies topped with our house made caramel, chocolate drizzle and a sprinkle of walnuts.

Brownies

$0.95

We use 2 different chocolates in this brownie and spread chocolate frosting on top. Chocolate, chocolate, chocolate!

gluten-free +$1.25

11 pop1 review

Pecan Brownies

$1.30

Pecans added to our decadent brownies with chocolate brownie icing.

112 pops

Crème De Menthe Brownies

$1.30

Chocolate brownie base, creme de menthe filling. Topped with chocolate ganache.

22 pops1 review

Blondies

$1.05

A chocolate-less brownie is a blondie. A butter brown sugar based bar with our coconut-pecan icing

11 pop1 review

Pies

Dutch Apple Pie

$24.95

We peel and cut Granny Smith apples and bake into this classic apple pie topped with a brown sugar streusel.

1 review

Pecan Pie

$24.95

Southern tradition of pecans and filling baked up right.

1 review

33 pops1 review

Fudge Pie

$22

Baked Fudge pie. Perfect with a dollop of whipped cream.

11 pop

Tollhouse Pie

$22

Chocolate and walnut filling. Perfect warmed up with vanilla ice cream.

44 pops

Key Lime Pie

$29.95

Key lime custard baked in a graham cracker crust. Topped with whipped cream.

Dessert Menu

Individual Desserts

Fresh Fruit Tarts

Key Lime Tarts

Chocolate Salted Caramel Tart

Crème Brulee

Cakepops

Flourless Chocolate Hearts

Mini Fruit Tarts

Mini Key Lime Tarts

Petit Fours

Eclairs

Cannoli

Rice Krispie Treats

Cupcakes

GF Yellow/ Double Fudge Cupcake

GF Strawberry Cupcake

Banana Pudding

Chocolate Strawberries

Layer Cakes

Caramel Cake

Double Fudge Cake/ Buttercream

Fresh Coconut Cake

Red Velvet Cake

Yellow Cake/Cooked Fudge Icing

Carrot Cake

Double Fudge Cake/Cooked Fudge Icing

German Chocolate Cake

Fresh Strawberry Cake

Yellow Cake/Buttercream

Chocolate Pecan

Italian Cream Cake

Hummingbird Cake

White Lady Cake

Pound Cake

Plain Pound/Caramel Icing

Plain Pound

Raspberry Swirled Lemon Pound

Coconut Pound

Plain Pound/Cooked Fudge Icing

Lemon Glazed Pound

Buttered Rum with Pecans

Bars

Lemon Bars

Caramel Walnut Brownies

Brownies

Pecan Brownies

Crème De Menthe Brownies

Blondies

Quick Breads

Pumpkin Bread

Blueberry Bread

Banana Nut Bread

Cran Orange Bread

Morning Options

Cinnamon Rolls

Muffins

Croissants

Strawberry Cheese Croissant

Pies

Dutch Apple Pie

Pecan Pie

Fudge Pie

Tollhouse Pie

Key Lime Pie

Stacks

Strawberry Lady

White Lady

Specialty & Seasonal Desserts

Flourless Chocolate Cake

Yule Log

Lemon Meringue Pie

Peppermint Brownies

Pumpkin Pie

Cookies

Snickerdoodle

Chocolate Chunk

Sugar

Peanut Butter

Oatmeal Raisin